Interpreting the study on early prostate cancer survival with Urologist and prostate cancer expert, Dr. Fred Saad

Toronto, ON – September 19, 2016: A study published last week in the New England Journal of Medicine followed men with localized (contained to the prostate) prostate cancer for 10 years as they underwent one of three randomized treatment streams has since been widely reported on. Notably, many of the headlines touched upon the same reassuring conclusion: whether participants were treated with radiation therapy, had their prostates removed altogether, or were simply monitored using Prostate-Specific Antigen (PSA) tests, survival after ten years was the same at 99 per cent.

In the following days, many nuanced interpretations have been made regarding the threat that prostate cancer actually poses and the value of screening and treatment. We asked Urologist and prostate cancer expert, Dr. Fred Saad of l’Université de Montréal to weigh in and help clarify the study’s findings.

1. What was the most important finding from the study for you and why?

The most important finding from this long awaited study confirms several things that are very important. First, that patients diagnosed early with prostate cancer have long survivals and over 90% of patients will not die of prostate cancer at 10 years. However, patients who are treated early rather than followed are at significantly reduced risk of disease progression and developing metastases. This allows patients to avoid additional treatment that is both costly and with side-effects. The most intriguing aspect of the study is the fact that 77% of patients actually had what we consider low-risk cancers. One may speculate that differences in outcome would have been even more dramatic had there been more patients with intermediate- or high-risk cancers.

2. What are the strengths and weaknesses of the study?

The most obvious strength is the fact that patients were randomized into 1 of the 3 approaches to newly diagnosed prostate cancer: Observation, surgery and radiation therapy. This is the best method to objectively evaluate the advantages and risks of each option. This is truly the first large and well conducted study that was able to effectively randomize patients.

3. How do the results from this study affect how you advise and manage your prostate cancer patients?

This confirms that patients need to be informed of their options, and that 1 size does not fit all. The pros and cons of each option need to be considered when deciding which option fits best in terms of patient priorities. It also clearly demonstrates that detecting and treating the disease early delays or prevents the risk of developing incurable metastatic prostate cancer. Obviously deciding whether to treat or not continues to be based on the agressivity of the cancer at the time of diagnosis as well as patient age and life expectancy. This is especially important when one considers that at 10 years there was no difference in the risk of dying from prostate cancer when diagnosed early.

Based on Dr. Saad’s responses, we can take away this very important message: while there is no one-size-fits-all solution to prostate cancer, and there are pros and cons to each decision, patients need to be informed of their options when deciding which option fits best in terms of patient priorities. In Canada, the majority of patients with low-risk cancers are managed with active surveillance and will get treatment only if there is evidence that the cancer is progressing. However, knowing whether a patient has low-risk prostate cancer or a more aggressive form that may be lethal requires that men be tested. More than anything else, this study has reinforced the fact that time is our greatest ally when faced with prostate cancer. With more time, we have more choice. Early detection truly is key.

Click here to learn more about the study.

About Prostate Cancer Canada

Prostate Cancer Canada is the leading national foundation dedicated to the prevention of the most common cancer in men through research, advocacy, education, support and awareness. As one of the largest investors in prostate cancer research in Canada, Prostate Cancer Canada is committed to continuous discovery in the areas of prevention, diagnosis, treatment, and support. For more information please visit or follow us on Twitter @ProstateCancerC or Facebook at Prostate Cancer Canada.


For more information:
Adam Milller
Prostate Cancer Canada
416-441-2131 ext. 235
Help us take the first steps toward prevention. Donate Now

Subscribe to our free monthly e-newsletter!

* indicates required


PCC Spotlight
Prostate Cancer Canada’s Rock the Road Raffle sells out for 5th consecutive year

February 23, 2018 – TORONTO, ON – For the fifth year and counting, Prostate Cancer Canada’s (PCC) Rock the Road Raffle brought together Ontarians from all walks of life to both support an important cause and gain a chance to win a one-of-a-kind dream car.

Do men’s toenails contain clues about prostate cancer prevention?

Toronto, January 29, 2018 – Funded by Prostate Cancer Canada (PCC), Dr.

Discovery of a promising new medication to block 'master key' of cancer growth

Vancouver, BC – For years, researchers have investigated approaches to prevent cancer-causing cells from multiplying in the body.

Click here for news archive